top of page
Writer's pictureRaw Doggin Pet Food

Balanced Dog Training vs. Positive-Only Training - A Comparative Guide

Updated: Jul 27, 2023

Dog training philosophies can differ significantly from one trainer to another. Two popular approaches include balanced dog training and positive-only dog training. Each has its own advantages and challenges, and understanding these methods can help you make an informed decision about what's best for you and your furry companion. Let's dive in!

balanced dog training, positive dog training

Balanced Dog Training


Balanced dog training is a method that combines both rewards and corrections to shape a dog's behavior. It utilizes all four quadrants of operant conditioning - positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, positive punishment, and negative punishment.


The balanced approach is rooted in the belief that while rewards motivate dogs to do what we want, corrections help discourage behaviors we don't want. As an example, a balanced trainer might use a treat and/or verbal praise to reward a dog for sitting on command (positive reinforcement) and a gentle leash correction and/or verbal correction if the dog pulls on the walk (positive punishment).


Balanced training offers flexibility and can be highly effective. It's crucial however to use corrections judiciously and proportionately, as excessive or improper punishment can lead to fear, anxiety, or aggression. It's about balance and using the right approach for each dog, not about dominating or overpowering a dog.


Positive-Only Dog Training


Positive-only dog training, also known as force-free or reward-based training, focuses on the use of positive reinforcement. It means using treats, toys, praise, or anything your dog finds enjoyable to encourage desired behaviors.


This method aims to make training a wholly positive experience, focusing on rewarding good behaviors rather than correcting undesired ones. If a dog does something wrong, a positive-only trainer would redirect the behavior rather than correct it.


For instance, if a dog is chewing on a shoe, the trainer might redirect the dog's attention to a suitable chew toy and then reward the dog for choosing the toy over the shoe. The lack of punishment makes it a low-stress approach for dogs.


While positive-only training can foster a great relationship between dogs and their owners, it might not be effective in curbing all unwanted behaviours, especially those that are self-rewarding like barking or digging.


Which Approach is Right for You?


Choosing between balanced training and positive-only training depends on numerous factors such as your dog's temperament, your personal philosophy towards training, and the specific behaviors you're trying to encourage or discourage. Some dogs might respond really well to positive-only training, while others need a balanced approach.


Regardless of the method chosen, training should always be a positive, enjoyable experience for both you and your dog. Respect, kindness, and patience should be at the forefront of any training method. It's not just about shaping your dog's behaviour, but also about building your dog's confidence and strengthening the relationship with your canine companion.


Happy Training!


RAW Doggin Pet Food

4 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page